In a way, this isn't fair. We're comparing a picture that was taken with a professional camera and that probably had numerous beauty technicians working on it, with of picture of a vulnerable Katy Perry who was just trying to sleep. I don't believe we will ever see an A-Lister truly without all make-up...on purpose. Yes, accidents will happen, cruel pranks by spouses will happen, and shameless stunts by your agent will definitely happen, but if they actually go on TV or a magazine article, they had waaay to much keeping them safe. What I mean is, Gaga might've had a bat in the cave but her stylist who dried her hair to broom-territory may have noticed it and removed it before the shoot. The lighting guys probably saw she had some eye crud. They wiped that out before the picture. Meanwhile, with Katy, she might be disqualified for still having some eyeliner on. All in all, I can't decide who's uglier without pretty-pretty make-up.
It'd be easier to decide if they took the blond out of Gaga's hair, and the raven out of Katy's hair and really did go natural.